Age/Gender: 19, Male
Location: Texas or something
Job: Squirrel shaver
Newgrounds Stats
Whistle Status: Normal
Exp. Points: 480 / 550
Exp. Rank #: 78,702
Voting Pow.: 4.92 votes
BBS Posts: 13 (0.01 per day)
Flash Reviews: 6
Music Reviews: 0
Trophies: 7
Stickers: 0
Entry #7
What I'm saying here is probably going to be controversial, considering the shorts themselves are quite revered. Therefore, I'd like anyone who disagrees with me to respond with why.
Of the two chapters of Valhalla Knights that have been released, I really wasn't impressed. I'm not talking about the animation quality; no, the animation itself is quite satisfactory. I'm referring to everything else.
From what I've seen, literally none of the story is original. A man who became a police officer because his father was killed by criminals, for example, is a trope not even limited to cop dramas (think Batman and Star Wars, for example). The line "It's not always like the movies, you know?" is the type of line that's so overused that I'm surprised it's not just used in parodies. Furthermore, Ken's statements in the first episode don't make any sense. He said smilingly "I like this job", mentioning that there was only one thing that bothered him about it (implied to be his boss), yet right after talking to him, he said "Man I'm done I better start looking for a new job" (sic). Was his boss yelling at him like that really such a bad experience that he didn't want to be a police officer anymore? Even though he was the one who was late? Is that really logical at all?
I'm going to skip over the "magical artifact handed over by dying ancestor" trope for now, because although it is used quite a bit, it can still be done respectably. Now I'm going to focus on the "naked young woman appearing out of nowhere who the protagonist has to take care of" trope. That part might seem interesting or even innovative if you haven't seen Chobits, Kono Mini, Elfen Lied, or... jeez, there was definitely a fourth one I had thought of, but I can't remember it for now. And Kono Mini and Elfen Lied took what was already a trope and subverted it (in pretty much the same way, actually)...
Basically, to sum it up, I don't see why people like the story so much. As a Flash, it's... erm... flashy, but if this were released as an actual film or television series, I really don't think it would be taken seriously. Are Newgrounds viewers not familiar with how much of the story was taken from other sources, or do they just not care? Or is it simply because it's well-animated for an amateur Flash?
I'd really like to see any dissenting opinions posted in comments here, not necessarily for debate purposes, but to help me understand why people like Valhalla Knights so much despite its (to me) lack of narrative merit.
P.S. I love those The Real Legend shorts and thought F E A R and Moonlight were pretty good.
Log in to comment! | Share this!The People Have Spoken
37 Comments